For-Profit Hospitals vs. Nonprofit: Key Differences
There are more than 6,000 hospitals in the U.S. Among these facilities, the two most common models are for-profit and nonprofit. Both models serve an overarching purpose of delivering healthcare services to the public, but each one is driven by distinct financial structures and regulations. So, what exactly are the differences between for-profit hospitals vs. non-profit hospitals?
Each of these hospital models comes with its own advantages and disadvantages. In this article, we’ll go over what a for-profit vs non-profit hospital is, discuss the pros and cons of each, and outline the key differences between the two.
What Is a Non-Profit Hospital?
Non-profit hospitals are driven by a mission to provide community service to the public, and therefore do not collect profit for the owners of the hospital. These hospitals instead use any excess revenue to improve their operations and make care more accessible. Because they’re managed under a charitable model, they maintain an official non-profit status in relation to the government and are exempt from paying taxes.
Pros and Cons of Non-Profit Hospitals
While the tax benefits of non-profit hospitals can be advantageous, they also come with a few operational limitations. Here are some of the more specific pros and cons of running a non-profit hospital.
| Exempt from local, state, and federal taxes and can therefore allocate more resources to providing healthcare services
Runs on a service and value-driven culture that’s less influenced by owner’s personal interests Has access to a range of public and private grants that support the organization’s mission |
Faces extensive paperwork with the IRS and other regulatory bodies to legally maintain non-profit status
Legally restricted from lobbying for healthcare reform due to non-profit status Must rely on funding from donors and be aggressive in fundraising efforts |
What Is a For-Profit Hospital?
Unlike non-profit hospitals, for-profit hospitals are run and organized like any other business. They prioritize earning revenue for shareholders and owners, and therefore are not exempt from taxes. The largest for-profit hospital system in the U.S. is HCA Healthcare, with headquarters in Nashville, TN, and many hospitals across 20 states. It’s estimated that 5% of U.S. hospital services are delivered at hospitals owned by HCA Healthcare.
Pros and Cons of For-Profit Hospitals
Just like non-profit hospitals, for-profit hospitals also come with their own unique set of benefits and challenges. We’ll summarize these in the table below.
| More financial stability and access to investments from shareholders
Prioritizes revenue and cost control, which can lead to greater efficiency in services Greater flexibility in adapting to the changing healthcare landscape due to financial structure and focus |
May have higher pricing structures, which can lead to inflated costs for patients
Greater risk of prioritizing profit over staff because of the need to create value for shareholders Receives less oversight than non-profit hospitals, which can limit transparency in financial practices and ethical standards |
For-Profit Hospitals vs Non-Profit Hospitals: 3 Differences
Now that we’ve more broadly answered the question, What is a non-profit hospital vs. for-profit hospital? we’ll highlight three key differences between these two models.
1. Ownership
A primary difference between for-profit hospitals vs. non-profit hospitals is the people running them. For-profit hospitals are owned by private entities and corporations, which are often publicly traded on the stock market.
Conversely, non-profit hospitals are often established by charitable organizations, religious groups, or community initiatives. These hospitals are required to operate through shared governance so that decisions are made by a board of trustees rather than a single entity.
2. Financial Structure
Another key difference in non-profit vs. for-profit hospitals is the financial structure driving each model. For-profit hospitals prioritize generating revenue for shareholders and owners. Thus, they focus on maximizing profit through investments, patient services, and insurance reimbursements.
But, how do non-profit hospitals make money? Unlike for-profit hospitals, non-profit organizations rely heavily on philanthropic donations, government grants, and tax exemptions. They’re also focused on investing back into the community, which can include facility improvements or investment in staff perks and benefits.
3. Resource Allocation
These differences in ownership and financing can also influence resource allocation. Non-profit hospitals focus on growing services that benefit the community, such as addiction recovery and psychiatric care. However, these types of services are not as profitable as others, making them less desirable for for-profit hospitals.
If you’re wondering, What does a non-profit hospital mean to the communities it serves? the answer often comes down to resources. Nonprofits are required to provide resources to the community, and must prove they’ve done so by meeting community benefit standards set out by the IRS.
For-profit hospitals may face financial pressures because of their need to balance the interests of shareholders. Because of this, they often put more money into advertising and marketing to increase their patient base. This also means that they’re more likely to invest in novel medical technologies and devices to help improve care efficiency.
How Do Patients Feel About Non-Profit vs. For-Profit Hospitals?
Studies have shown that non-profit and for-profit status actually have very little influence over where patients seek care. Additionally, experts have stated that there are no substantial differences in care quality between for-profit and not-for-profit healthcare organizations. Both types of hospitals follow distinct regulations and operational objectives, but fundamentally share the same goal of providing quality care to as many patients as possible.
The lack of difference in the quality of services can make it challenging to distinguish between types when seeking care. Patients may wonder: Are most hospitals non-profit, and is the service going to be on par with a for-profit institution? About two-thirds of U.S. hospitals are designated as nonprofits. In some states, such as Vermont, Delaware, and Rhode Island, a high percentage of the hospitals are nonprofit. In states with a mix of facility business models, it’s unlikely that patients will choose one hospital over another based on ownership status alone.
What Is a Not-for-Profit Hospital? Is it the Same as a Non-Profit Hospital?
In everyday conversation, the terms non-profit hospital and not-for-profit hospital are often used to mean the same thing: a hospital that doesn’t generate profit for private owners and stakeholders. However, when it comes to legalities and finances, there are distinctions. While neither generates profit for private gains, a not-for-profit organization (NFPO) can earn income that is reinvested into a private group. For example, an NFPO teaching hospital may earn profits that are then reinvested into the organization to support future educational activities.
Get the Information You Need, When You Need It
If you’re looking to build a deeper understanding of the healthcare industry, differentiating for-profit hospitals vs. non-profit hospitals is just the beginning. Get more expert-written healthcare management tips and insights delivered straight to your inbox.