Union Hospitals vs. Nonunion Hospitals: What’s the Difference?
When choosing where to work as a nurse or healthcare professional, one big factor to consider is whether to work at a union or nonunion hospital. Union hospitals are facilities where the staff is represented by a labor union, which is an organized group of individuals that advocates for workplace protection, fair wages, and other essential benefits. Nonunion hospitals, on the other hand, handle these matters directly between employer and employee, without union representation.
Curious about which work setting is a better fit for you? This article breaks down what it’s like to work at a unionized hospital versus a nonunion one so you can decide which environment best supports your goals.
What Is a Union Hospital?
Union hospitals are healthcare facilities where employees — such as nurses, medical assistants, and other healthcare staff members — are represented by a labor union. These unions serve as a collective voice for workers, advocating for better working conditions, higher wages, safe staffing levels, and fair scheduling practices.
Union representation can significantly improve the day-to-day experience of healthcare workers. When staff are part of a union, they have the legal right to collectively bargain — meaning they can negotiate as a group for better work conditions. Benefits commonly associated with employment at union hospitals can include:
| Benefit | Description |
|---|---|
| Improved job protection | Union contracts may include rules around disciplinary procedures, termination, and grievance resolution, protecting staff from unfair dismissal. |
| Potentially higher pay and benefits | Unionized healthcare workers often earn more and are more likely to have employer-sponsored health insurance and retirement plans than their nonunion counterparts. |
| Advocacy for safer staffing levels | Many healthcare unions actively campaign for safe staffing ratios to help reduce burnout and improve patient care. |
| Stronger voice in the workplace | Union healthcare workers have a voice not just in their workplace, but also in shaping broader policies that impact working conditions and patient care. |
| Support during workplace challenges | Union contracts provide a formal process to resolve disputes. Additionally, members can rely on trained representatives to provide guidance and advocate on their behalf. |
Unionization can happen in two main ways:
- Through an organizing campaign and vote: Nurses at a nonunion hospital can form or join a union by going through a legal process that includes petitioning, voting, and presenting a contract to management.
- Union security agreements: Nurses who are hired into a hospital or health system that already has a union contract may automatically become members and pay representation fees.
Being part of a union usually means:
- Nurses are covered under a collective bargaining agreement (CBA).
- Nurses have access to union representatives for workplace issues.
- Nurses contribute dues or fees that support union activities.
What Is a Nonunion Hospital?
A nonunion hospital is a healthcare facility where employees negotiate their wages, benefits, and working conditions individually or directly with management, without the involvement of a labor union. Unlike union hospitals, decisions about staffing, scheduling, and workplace policies are typically made by hospital administrators.
Working in a nonunion hospital can have its advantages and drawbacks. Staff may find greater freedom in negotiating pay or adjusting their schedules, plus the opportunity for more direct communication with management and leadership teams. However, healthcare workers may have fewer formal protections when it comes to addressing workplace issues.
Potential benefits of nonunion hospitals include the following:
| Benefit | Description |
|---|---|
| Direct employer-employee negotiations | Employees usually negotiate salaries, schedules, and benefits on an individual basis, which may work better for some individuals. |
| Potential for quicker decision-making | Without union negotiations, management may be able to implement changes more quickly. |
| Potential for merit-based rewards | Nonunion environments sometimes offer more flexibility for rewarding top performers with raises or bonuses that are not bound by union contracts. |
| Less formalized work rules | Nonunion hospitals may have fewer rigid policies, allowing managers and employees to adapt quickly to changing conditions or individual circumstances. |
| Potentially lower dues or fees | Employees do not pay union dues or fees, which can mean more take-home pay or savings for those who prefer to avoid those costs. |
Hospitals With Nursing Unions: What It Means
Across the U.S., there are many hospitals that operate under union contracts with nursing staff. These unions work to push for systemic changes that affect both employees and patient care and are usually part of larger organizations that operate at the national or regional level.
Here are some examples of the nursing unions in the U.S.:
- National Nurses United (NNU) is the largest union of registered nurses in the U.S., with over 225,000 members.
- California Nurses Association (CNA) represents about 100,000 registered nurses at more than 200 facilities.
- New York State Nurses Association (NYSNA) represents over 42,000 nurses across the state.
- Minnesota Nurses Association (MNA) represents about 22,000 nurses and other healthcare workers in Minnesota and across state lines in Wisconsin, North Dakota, and Iowa.
- Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Nurse Alliance represents over 80,000 RNs in 21 states and licensed practical nurses across the country.
- United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP) represents over 40,000 thousand nurses and healthcare professionals.
Here are some examples of hospitals with nursing union representation:
Nurse Unions by State: Understanding Regional Differences
Your experience of working in union hospitals can vary significantly by state. Labor laws, union density, and healthcare infrastructure all play a role in how strongly nurses are represented — and what that representation looks like. In states like California, New York, and Minnesota, nurse unions are deeply established and play a major role in shaping healthcare policy and workplace conditions. In other states, union presence may be small or growing.
In contrast, right-to-work states such as Alabama, Florida, and Indiana have far fewer unionized hospitals. In these states, organizing efforts face more legal and political obstacles, and union membership tends to be lower. While it’s still possible for nurses to form or join unions, the process may require navigating additional legal hurdles and gaining broader support among employees.
Choosing the Right Fit: Union Hospitals vs. Nonunion Hospitals
Choosing the right work environment depends on your personal priorities, career goals, and values. Some nurses thrive in unionized hospitals where they benefit from strong collective support, structured contracts, and a clear voice in workplace decisions. Others may prefer the flexibility, individual negotiation opportunities, and less formal structure that a nonunion hospital can provide.
When deciding which hospital works best for you, ask yourself the following questions:
- Do you value collective bargaining power and stronger job protections?
- Would you rather negotiate your own pay and benefits?
- Is job stability and safe staffing more important, or are you looking for performance-based rewards?
- How much do you want to be involved in workplace policy decisions?
Where you live also plays a role. The influence of unions varies significantly across the nation. Understanding your state’s labor laws and union presence can help guide your decision.
Discover Nursing Jobs on IntelyCare
Whether you want to explore roles at union hospitals or nonunion facilities, we can help you get access to quality nursing jobs that match your needs. Get access to a personalized job search experience where your priorities matter most.