What Is a Noncompliance Nursing Diagnosis?

A noncompliance nursing diagnosis isn’t just another clinical label. This diagnosis reflects a real struggle nurses face in bridging the gap between treatment plans and patients’ realities.

Picture a patient with diabetes who knows the importance of taking insulin but skips doses because the cost is overwhelming or because she says she feels fine without it. Today, she’s back in the hospital with diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) — again. Understanding noncompliance helps nurses uncover the why behind a patient’s choices, creating opportunities for personalized interventions.

So what exactly does noncompliance mean in nursing, and what can be done about it? This article will walk you through the definition, the common causes behind it, and practical strategies you can use to address it effectively.

What Is Noncompliance in Medical Terms?

In nursing practice, noncompliance is sometimes known as ineffective health management or ineffective adherence, and is identified as a North American Nursing Diagnosis Association (NANDA) diagnosis. It’s applicable in situations in which a patient or their caregiver does not follow healthcare recommendations or a prescribed treatment plan. This may involve missing medications, skipping follow-up appointments, or neglecting lifestyle changes that are necessary to manage the condition.

Within the NANDA taxonomy, noncompliance was classified as a behavioral nursing diagnosis. Specifically, it falls under “Domain 1: Health Promotion” and “Class 2: Health Management.” The official definition of noncompliance is:

“Behavior of a person and/or caregiver that fails to coincide with a health-promoting or therapeutic plan agreed upon by the person (and/or family and/or community) and healthcare professional. In the presence of an agreed-upon health-promoting or therapeutic plan, the person’s or caregiver’s behavior is fully or partially nonadherent and may lead to clinically ineffective or partially effective outcomes.”

Noncompliance Nursing Diagnosis: Related Factors and Defining Characteristics

Every nursing diagnosis is defined by its causes (related factors) as well as signs and symptoms (defining characteristics). These elements are important because they guide nurses in accurately identifying the patient’s problem, determining the underlying reasons for noncompliance, and developing targeted, effective interventions.

Factors that can increase the likelihood of noncompliance can be grouped into a few main areas:

Defining characteristics are the signs and symptoms that show a patient isn’t following their care plan — they’re basically the evidence you need to see that noncompliance is happening. These can be broken down into what the patient tells you (subjective clues) and what you can observe (objective clues):

Noncompliance Nursing Diagnosis: 5 Tips for Nurses

Noncompliance isn’t just a behavior — it’s also a clue. By diving into the why behind the behavior, nurses can uncover the real reasons behind nonadherence. Once you understand the causes — whether emotional, financial, social, or cultural — you can design interventions that truly make a difference. Here are five strategies that may help you deal with noncompliant patients.

1. Understand Illness Denial

Illness denial is a common response that many patients exhibit when they first learn about a new diagnosis. While it serves as a coping mechanism to deal with the shock that comes when a patient learns they have an illness, it can significantly delay treatment, affect adherence to prescribed therapeutic interventions, and, sometimes, lead to adverse outcomes.

As a nurse, it’s important to understand the psychological mechanisms at play when a patient learns they have a condition to help them work through it. One strategy you may implement is to acknowledge their feelings without judgment while gently guiding them toward understanding their diagnosis.

For example, imagine you’re a cardiovascular nurse caring for a yoga teacher newly diagnosed with hypertension. She refuses medication, saying, “It can’t be happening to me. I’ve been vegan for over a decade — I can’t have hypertension.”

You might respond: “I understand this is hard to believe; it must be a shock. Many people feel the same way when they find out they have a health condition. But your lab results do confirm the diagnosis. The good news is we can work together on a treatment plan that fits your life.”

2. Help Patients Feel Accepted

A common reason patients don’t share the real reason behind noncompliance is shame. For example, a patient with diabetes may feel embarrassed to admit they can’t stick to a low-sugar diet. Or a patient may feel embarrassed to admit they can’t afford their prescriptions, which is typical for a medication noncompliance nursing diagnosis.

By using therapeutic communication tools, nurses can break down shame, uncover hidden obstacles, and guide patients toward practical solutions that fit their lives and circumstances.

Here are some strategies to help patients feel safe to open up about their struggle with adherence to a treatment plan:

• Normalize the struggle. Let patients know that what they’re experiencing is common. You might say, “Many people with this condition face the same challenges. Have you ever experienced this? If so, there are resources that can help.” This reduces feelings of isolation and encourages patients to seek support rather than suffer in silence.
• Create a safe space for discussion. Approach the topic gently. The goal is to gradually build trust so patients feel comfortable sharing the real barriers to adherence.

3. Connect Patients to Support Resources

Support networks can make a big difference in helping patients stick to their treatment plans. Many patients benefit from peer support groups or condition-specific fellowships, where they can share experiences, gain encouragement, and learn practical strategies from others facing similar challenges.

For example, a patient struggling with diabetes management might join a local diabetes support group or a local running club. Someone recovering from addiction might benefit from a 12-step program or a professionally led group. Connecting with others facing similar challenges provides ongoing support and encouragement, making adherence more likely.

4. Use Motivational Interviewing to Encourage Change

Noncompliance often stems from ambivalence, not defiance. Rather than simply instructing patients to follow their care plan, motivational interviewing helps patients explore their own reasons for change and commit to action.

Motivational Interviewing flows through four core processes, though nurses may move back and forth as needed:

• Engaging: Build trust through empathetic listening, affirming strengths, and supporting autonomy.
• Focusing: Work together to set a clear agenda and shared goals for the conversation.
• Evoking: Explore the patient’s own reasons for change, addressing ambivalence without judgment and strengthening motivation.
• Planning: When the patient is ready, help them turn motivation into concrete steps for change.

5. Leverage Technology and Reminders

Nonadherence can stem from both forgetfulness and a lack of knowledge about the prescribed regimen. A knowledge deficit nursing care plan helps identify these gaps, and technology can support patients in bridging them. Using reminder apps, medication trackers, or visual aids, nurses can provide patients with the tools they need to understand their treatment, take medications correctly, and maintain adherence over time.

Here are a few examples of apps your patients can try to boost compliance:

• Medisafe
• MySugr
• EveryDose
• Meds and Pill Reminder MyTherapy
• Max

Noncompliance Nursing Diagnosis: FAQs

Is noncompliance a NANDA nursing diagnosis?

Yes. Noncompliance is recognized as a behavioral nursing diagnosis by the NANDA-I. It refers to a patient or caregiver’s behavior that does not align with an agreed-upon health-promoting or therapeutic plan.

What is a nursing diagnosis for medication noncompliance?

Any NANDA nursing diagnosis follows the following structure:

• Problem/diagnosis
• Related factors
• Defining characteristics

Here’s an example of how a diagnosis describing medication noncompliance might sound: “Noncompliance (medication) related to financial barriers and knowledge deficit as evidenced by missed doses and patient reporting inability to afford prescribed medications.”

Ineffective health management nursing diagnosis vs. noncompliance: What’s the difference?

The term noncompliance specifically addresses situations where a patient fails to follow a prescribed therapeutic regimen. This term has been critiqued for its potential to imply blame and for not adequately capturing the complexities of patient behavior. Consequently, NANDA-I retired the noncompliance label and replaced it with ineffective health management and ineffective health maintenance.

It’s important to note that NANDA-I regularly updates and revises its taxonomy to reflect evolving evidence and best practices. Diagnosis labels may change, so it’s always best to consult the most recent NANDA-I Nursing Diagnoses: Definitions and Classification that can be found on the official website.

Find Best-Fitting Nursing Jobs With IntelyCare

Every day, nurses face challenges like the noncompliance nursing diagnosis — and every day, your work changes lives. IntelyCare connects you with the latest nursing jobs that align with your interests and skills. Discover roles that fit your needs today.