Is It Better to Become a Doctor or Nurse? Career Comparison

Are you trying to decide whether to become a doctor or nurse? With nearly 4.7 million registered nurses (RNs) and more than 1 million active physicians in the U.S. alone, both professions are in high demand — but the paths to each are vastly different.

So which path offers the better return for your time, money, and personal fulfillment? We’ll help you find out. This article compares the education, responsibilities, and salaries of each role to help you choose the career path that best fits your goals.

Doctor or Nurse: Quick Facts

Doctor or Nurse: Educational Journeys

One of the most important differences between becoming a doctor or nurse lies in the education and training required for each role. Both careers are essential to healthcare, but the time, cost, and intensity of preparation can vary dramatically. Generally speaking, doctors undergo a far longer and more expensive training process, while nurses can enter the workforce much sooner and at a lower cost.

Becoming a Doctor

Aspiring doctors must prepare for a long and rigorous academic journey that can take a minimum of 11 years from start to finish. Here’s a step-by-step overview of the typical process:

• Step 1: Earn a bachelor’s degree, typically in 4 years, often focused on pre-medical coursework such as biology, chemistry, and physics.
• Step 2: Take the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT), a standardized exam that assesses critical thinking, scientific knowledge, and problem-solving skills. It is required for admission to medical school.
• Step 3: Attend medical school, which lasts another 4 years. The first 2 years usually focus on classroom-based learning, while the final 2 years involve clinical rotations in various specialties like internal medicine, surgery, pediatrics, and psychiatry.
• Step 4: Complete residency, which provides hands-on training in a chosen specialty and typically lasts 3 to 7 years. Some doctors go on to complete a fellowship for additional specialization (e.g., cardiology, oncology, surgery).
• Step 5: Attain licensing and board certification by passing the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) or Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Examination of the United States (COMLEX-USA) exams, followed by board certification in a chosen specialty.

It generally takes more than a decade to become a practicing doctor, depending on your chosen specialty and training route. But it’s not just time that’s required — becoming a doctor also involves a significant financial investment.

According to the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), the average cost of attending a public medical school is over $250,000, while private institutions can exceed $330,000 in tuition and fees alone. And this doesn’t include the cost of a four-year undergraduate degree.

Becoming a Nurse

For those looking to enter the healthcare field more quickly, becoming a nurse offers a shorter and more flexible educational pathway. While RNs don’t require the extensive years of training that doctors do, their education is still rigorous and essential to ensuring high-quality patient care. Here’s a look at the typical steps involved:

• Step 1: Complete a nursing program. The most common entry-level options are the Associate Degree in Nursing (ADN), which typically takes about 2 years, or the Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN), which takes about 4 years.
• Step 2: Obtain RN licensure by passing the NCLEX-RN exam, a comprehensive test that evaluates a nurse’s ability to deliver safe and effective care. After passing, candidates must submit the required documents to their state board of nursing to receive official licensure.

Overall, the process of becoming an RN usually takes between two to four years, depending on the educational path chosen. Tuition for an ADN typically ranges from $2,000 to $25,000 per year at community colleges. For those pursuing a BSN at a university, the cost can range from $13,000 to $100,000 per year, depending on whether the school is public or private.

Doctor or Nurse: Job Responsibilities

If you’re weighing the decision to become a doctor or nurse, it’s important to understand that the day-to-day responsibilities, level of authority, and scope of practice differ significantly for these roles.

With additional education and certification, some RNs — such as those who become certified registered nurse anesthetists (CRNAs) or certified nurse midwives (CNMs) — can take on responsibilities that closely resemble those of physicians, including prescribing medications and diagnosing illnesses.
 

Doctor vs. Nurse: Salary

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), the average annual salary for physicians is $253,470, although this figure can vary widely depending on the specialty. In contrast, the average annual salary for RNs in the U.S. is $98,430.

That said, nurses who take on advanced roles can significantly increase their income. For example, NPs earn an average of $132,000 per year, while CRNAs are among the highest-paid nursing professionals, bringing in $231,700 annually on average.

Regardless of whether you’re a nurse or doctor, your salary can vary based on factors such as experience, education level, workplace setting, and geographic location. For example, some of the highest-paying states for nurses include:

• California
• Hawaii
• Oregon
• Washington
• Massachusetts

Doctor or Nurse: Which Is Better for You?

Deciding between becoming a doctor or a nurse ultimately comes down to your personal goals, lifestyle preferences, financial situation, and desired impact within the healthcare system. While both roles are deeply rewarding and essential to patient care, they differ significantly in scope of practice and career trajectory.

Doctor vs. Nurse: FAQs

What is the job outlook for a doctor vs. nurse?

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), RN employment is projected to grow 6% from 2023 to 2033, while advanced practice roles like NPs are expected to grow much faster at 40%. In contrast, physician and surgeon roles are projected to grow by 4% during the same period, with some specialties like psychiatry seeing higher demand.

Should I be a nurse or a doctor?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the question. It really depends on your goals, interests, and desired lifestyle. If you’re torn between becoming a doctor or nursing, consider volunteering at healthcare facilities to get a real sense of what each role is like. Talk to doctors and nurses about their experiences and how satisfied they are with their career choices — their insights can help guide your decision.

Can a nurse become a doctor?

Yes, you can go from RN to MD. You’ll need to complete a pre-med bachelor’s degree (if you don’t already have one), take the MCAT, attend medical school, and finish residency — a process that can take around seven to nine years (or more).

Can nurses work independently?

While RNs typically work under the supervision of primary care providers, NPs in full practice authority states can work independently. This means they can diagnose, prescribe, and manage care without needing a doctor’s supervision. Laws vary by state, so check what applies in your area.

What is job satisfaction like for nurses compared to doctors?

Studies show that nurses typically have higher job satisfaction than doctors, yet both groups struggle with stress and burnout, particularly in hospitals.

What types of specialties are available for nurses and doctors?

Nurses and doctors have a wide variety of specialties to choose from. Here’s a simple chart showing common specialties for nurses and doctors:

Doctor or Nurse: What’s Your Next Job?

Interested in finding a healthcare job that truly matches your needs? IntelyCare can help you build the career you want and deserve. Find out how you can unlock nursing opportunities designed around your needs.